Cancel culture has become a visible force in how students discuss accountability, forgiveness and free expression, particularly in online spaces. While it is often intended to address harmful behavior, some students question whether public callouts lead to personal growth or simply serve as punishment.
Many students say cancel culture was created to hold people accountable, but they believe it has shifted toward excessive consequences, especially on social media. Posts, screenshots and comment threads can quickly turn into widespread criticism, leaving little room for context or discussion.
“I think cancel culture can be both helpful and harmful, but more so harmful when it turns into harassment instead of accountability,” junior Aniya Williams said.
Social media platforms play a central role in how cancel culture spreads among students. Information, opinions and accusations can circulate within minutes, shaping public perception before all details are known. This rapid pace often leads to snap judgments and heightened reactions.
“We’re in a time period now where information spreads quickly and fast, so it affects public opinion,” Williams said. “I think cancel culture can make students more afraid to share their opinions because of the fear of getting backlash.”
Several students said cancel culture can discourage open discussion at school, creating an environment where people hesitate to express viewpoints that differ from the majority. Even when opinions are not harmful, the fear of criticism or social exclusion can silence conversation.
“Especially nowadays, a lot of people may have their own separate opinions,” junior Garyn Washington said. “They could get shunned for something they believe in.”
Students also expressed mixed opinions on whether people deserve second chances after being canceled. Some believe forgiveness should depend on the severity of the action, while others argue that accountability should include opportunities for growth and change.
“It depends on what they did,” senior Addella Bissell said. “If it’s something stupid that people are being weird about, then yeah, but if it’s like a big crime, then I don’t think they should get a second chance.”
While many students agree that cancel culture began with good intentions, some believe it has become harmful when punishment outweighs understanding. Social media often amplifies these effects, making thoughtful dialogue more difficult.
“Holding somebody accountable focuses on growth and change, whereas cancelling someone focuses on punishment and exclusion,” Williams said.
